11 Comments

Worth it just for the impersonation.

Also big positive/zero sum energy, if Mr Wright is struggling for a topic next time you chat.

Jon Haidt's version is common humanity which captures that much political gnashing of teeth is actually garden variety... envy.

Also: top Substack joke-teller 💪

Expand full comment
founding
Nov 13, 2023Liked by Paul Bloom

Thought-provoking as usual Professor.

First, I’d like to offer the idea (not mine*, so please don’t anyone envy me if you wish you’d thought of it) that greed is the mother of all sin, which I interpret as excessive (harmful) desire for anything. Thus greed = excessive desire = sin. Sloth is greed for comfort; gluttony is greed for food and drink; lust is greed for sex. Pride and anger, as you mention, are only sinful in excess - this is a language problem. For example, excess is built into the meaning of gluttony. Excessive pride is greed to feel superior (excessive self-worth); excessive anger is the feeling of being wronged plus excessive pride; and envy is anger plus greed for what another has (coveting). So, in a sense, your thesis that envy is the worst is understandable, as it contains anger, which contains pride, plus coveting!

Second, I would have added three other whoppers to the list of 7: authoritarianism - greed to control others; cowardice - greed for safety; and attention-seeking - greed for attention. ‘Nuff said these days, I reckon.

Third, and finally, my recommendation to overcome envy: learn to be happy with who you are, not what you do or have. Then your only worry is sloth!

* From one of Idries Shah’s books; sorry, I don’t remember which one. My explication of the idea is my own, though.

Expand full comment
Nov 14, 2023Liked by Paul Bloom

Perfect post for the day's wordle!

Expand full comment
Nov 13, 2023Liked by Paul Bloom

This is my hearty congratulations to you for a great post and for writing a great Substack!

[shoves his substack envy way down into his boots]

Expand full comment
Nov 13, 2023Liked by Paul Bloom

Great stuff! I think you could also come at envy from a clinical perspective. What core beliefs are underpinning our sense that we should have what a close other has? Are we aware when we're filtering out the good stuff, failing to count our blessings? I think it helps to help a client identify those core beliefs and recognize that filter.

I guess you're getting at that with the idea of consciously switching the hierarchy, but my instinct is to explore deeper existential issues. I'd expect once someone deals with why another's good fortune is threatening, the envy dissipates.

Expand full comment
Nov 13, 2023Liked by Paul Bloom

And when I speak of you, I see envy in other men's eyes

And I'm well aware of what's on their minds

They pretend to be my friend, when all the time

They long to persuade you from my side

They'd give the world and all they own

For just one moment we have known

"Bernadette" - The Four Tops

Expand full comment

WOW! The Oppenheimer story is quite shocking. How a man can be so gifted in one area and lacking in another...

Expand full comment

Thanks, Paul, for a great read as always! I wonder if we are the only ones who get envious, how we evolved to be so, and at what age we develop it. Though I sense only a whole book would answer this.

Expand full comment

"...and with luck, your spirit will come into synch with your actions." A smart caveat! As per your own observation: we can fake our actions/gestures but not our feelings. A feeling sublimated in forced action is liable to rebound if one is "without luck".

Expand full comment

I understand that billionaires envy one another, but I don't understand why. And I don't understand why so many billionaires fight so hard to keep unions away or to avoid paying taxes. It seems to me the point of getting rich is that you don't have to worry about money anymore. But that doesn't seem to be how it works. Why not?

Expand full comment
author

For many of us, you're right -- the point of getting rich is security from financial worry. But billionaires have different ambitions. (You don't need a billion to be financially secure.) For them, the money is a means to some other end.

Expand full comment