Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Leon Hewer's avatar

Worth it just for the impersonation.

Also big positive/zero sum energy, if Mr Wright is struggling for a topic next time you chat.

Jon Haidt's version is common humanity which captures that much political gnashing of teeth is actually garden variety... envy.

Also: top Substack joke-teller 💪

Expand full comment
dmm's avatar

Thought-provoking as usual Professor.

First, I’d like to offer the idea (not mine*, so please don’t anyone envy me if you wish you’d thought of it) that greed is the mother of all sin, which I interpret as excessive (harmful) desire for anything. Thus greed = excessive desire = sin. Sloth is greed for comfort; gluttony is greed for food and drink; lust is greed for sex. Pride and anger, as you mention, are only sinful in excess - this is a language problem. For example, excess is built into the meaning of gluttony. Excessive pride is greed to feel superior (excessive self-worth); excessive anger is the feeling of being wronged plus excessive pride; and envy is anger plus greed for what another has (coveting). So, in a sense, your thesis that envy is the worst is understandable, as it contains anger, which contains pride, plus coveting!

Second, I would have added three other whoppers to the list of 7: authoritarianism - greed to control others; cowardice - greed for safety; and attention-seeking - greed for attention. ‘Nuff said these days, I reckon.

Third, and finally, my recommendation to overcome envy: learn to be happy with who you are, not what you do or have. Then your only worry is sloth!

* From one of Idries Shah’s books; sorry, I don’t remember which one. My explication of the idea is my own, though.

Expand full comment
11 more comments...

No posts