Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Tombarriesimmons's avatar

Very interesting. I guess at my age, and being an Englishman, albeit one who has travelled well, comic books was such a small part of my life, and one that I didn't find particularly interesting, my childhood and teenage years was shaped by thinking, observing, and interacting with people who I knew in the village I grew up in. Consequently, I have never thought of people being other than various shades of grey.

C. Connor Syrewicz's avatar

» “Now there are two ways to think about how this moral judgment works within large societies, and our article doesn’t distinguish them. The less interesting possibility is that everyone applies these coarse categories to people they don’t know well. The only difference between the Hadza and us is that they don’t have as many strangers to judge. But when it comes to thinking about people we are close to, we, like the Hadza, make fine-grained moral distinctions. We recognize that our friends have complex moral profiles, and we don’t collapse them into good and bad.”

I think this is actually the more interesting possibility. The Hadza spend a lot of time with a band of thirty or so people (which is a lot of people to be living closely and intimately with, when you think about it) who they inevitably, due to their lifestyle, know very well, which leads them develop to a relatively nuanced mental model of “people,” which leads to relatively fine-grained moral judgements. In larger societies, you’re meeting more strangers but also you are living closely and intimately with fewer people. You may have thirty-or-so friends, family menbers, co-workers, etc. with whom you feel close (though thirty still sounds like a lot), but ultimately, you’re still spending less time with those thirty people and are not living closely and intimately with them at the very least. Your exposure to people is now much less psychologically rich: your perception of them is created at a greater distance, your model of “people” becomes coarser because of this distance, and so too do the moral distinctions you make. This would explain both the differences between the Hadza and people in WEIRD societies and the effect that going to larger societies had on the Hadza. Our mental models of “people” have simplified, so of course how we judge “people” has also simplified. And if there’s anything that feels very true to me right now about our society, it’s that we have very simple mental models of what people and their lives, in their infinite, unfathomable strangeness and variety, are really like.

Ready for more?